The Elusive Absolute Surface Air Temperature (SAT)

Summary: The two-centuries long warming of the Earth’s surface (~1.4° Fahrenheit) since 1880) might become one of the most important trends of the 21st century. But, like so many aspects of science, it is a complex phenomenon inadequately understood by the public — and poorly explained by the news media and climate advocates. Here’s a brief, clear explanation of the starting point: The Elusive Absolute Surface Air Temperature. Please post your thoughts about this in the comments.

775 Warming

Great propaganda! Too bad it’s failed.


Q.  What exactly do we mean by Surface Air Temperature (SAT) ?

A.  I doubt that there is a general agreement how to answer this question. Even at the same location, the temperature near the ground may be very different from the temperature 5 ft above the ground and different again from 10 ft or 50 ft above the ground. Particularly in the presence of vegetation (say in a rain forest), the temperature above the vegetation may be very different from the temperature below the top of the vegetation.

A reasonable suggestion might be to use the average temperature of the first 50 ft of air either above ground or above the top of the vegetation. To measure SAT we have to agree on what it is and, as far as I know, no such standard has been suggested or generally adopted. Even if the 50 ft standard were adopted, I cannot imagine that a weather station would build a 50 ft stack of thermometers to be able to find the true SAT at its location.

Q.  What do we mean by daily mean SAT ?

A.  Again, there is no universally accepted correct answer. Should we note the temperature every 6 hours and report the mean, should we do it every 2 hours, hourly, have a machine record it every second, or simply take the average of the highest and lowest temperature of the day ? On some days the various methods may lead to drastically different results.

Warming thermostat

Great over-the-top graphic!


Q.  What SAT do the local media report ?

A.  The media report the reading of 1 particular thermometer of a nearby weather station. This temperature may be very different from the true SAT even at that location and has certainly nothing to do with the true regional SAT. To measure the true regional SAT, we would have to use many 50 ft stacks of thermometers distributed evenly over the whole region, an obvious practical impossibility.

Q.  If the reported SATs are not the true SATs, why are they still useful ?

A.  The reported temperature is truly meaningful only to a person who happens to visit the weather station at the precise moment when the reported temperature is measured, in other words, to nobody. However, in addition to the SAT the reports usually also mention whether the current temperature is unusually high or unusually low, how much it differs from the normal temperature, and that information (the anomaly) is meaningful for the whole region.

Also, if we hear a temperature (say 70°F), we instinctively translate it into hot or cold, but our translation key depends on the season and region, the same temperature may be ‘hot’ in winter and ‘cold’ in July, since by ‘hot’ we always mean ‘hotter than normal’, i.e. we all translate absolute temperatures automatically into anomalies whether we are aware of it or not.

Q.  If SATs cannot be measured, how are SAT maps created ?

A.  This can only be done with the help of computer models, the same models that are used to create the daily weather forecasts. We may start out the model with the few observed data that are available and fill in the rest with guesses (also called extrapolations) and then let the model run long enough so that the initial guesses no longer matter, but not too long in order to avoid that the inaccuracies of the model become relevant. This may be done starting from conditions from many years, so that the average (called a ‘climatology’) hopefully represents a typical map for the particular month or day of the year.

Q.  What do I do if I need absolute SATs, not anomalies ?

A.  In 99.9% of the cases you’ll find that anomalies are exactly what you need, not absolute temperatures. In the remaining cases, you have to pick one of the available climatologies and add the anomalies (with respect to the proper base period) to it. For the global mean, the most trusted models produce a value of roughly 14°C, i.e. 57.2°F, but it may easily be anywhere between 56 and 58°F and regionally, let alone locally, the situation is even worse.

Original source here. A hat tip for the info to here. Post your thoughts about this analysis in the comments.

More about measuring the temperature of the world

  • Heat Storage Within The Earth System“, Roger Pielke Sr (eminent climate scientist; see Wikipedia), Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society, March 2003.
  • Does a Global Temperature Exist?“, Christopher Essex (Prof Applied Mathematics, U Western Ontario) and Ross McKitrick (Prof Economics, U Guelph), and Bjarne Andreson (Prof Physics, U Copenhagen), Journal of Non-Equilibrium Thermodynamics, February 2007

For More Information

Reference Pages about climate on the FM sites:

Other posts about global warming:

  1. Good news! Global temperatures have stabilized, at least for now., 3 February 2012
  2. Still good news: global temperatures remain stable, at least for now., 14 October 2012
  3. When did we start global warming? See the surprising answer (it’s not what you’ve been told)., 18 October 2012
  4. The IPCC sees the pause in global warming!, 18 December 2012
  5. Lessons about global warming from Alaska, 9 January 2013
  6. Secrets about global warming that you must not know, least they ruin the narrative, 22 January 2013
  7. Lessons about America to be learned from the Climate Wars, 28 June 2013
  8. Good news about climate change!, 15 July 2013
  9. Hidden news about our weather in July: experts tell us what even well-informed people do not know., 8 August 2013

About climate propaganda



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s