The first step on the road to America’s reform

This site has had many discussions about reforming America.   How to put us back on the path to security, prosperity, and freedom.  Recalling who we are.  The need is admitted by all, but the means — the process of reform — remains unclear.

I have suggested several ways this can run, but none have been convincing.  Not to me.  Not to most folks posting comments.  The most difficult step is the first, and so far none can see how to spark the process.  This posts takes another shot at finding a solution.

  1. The problem
  2. A first step to a solution
  3. The second step to a solution
  4. Afterword, and For more information about these questions

(1)  The Problem

America needs reform, as our citizens become passive consumers of government services.  Become sheep, unable to make the mental and moral effort required to run the Constitutional machinery.

Under a republican form of government the citizenry supposedly accepts the responsibility for managing its own affairs, but over the last quarter of a century the heirs to the American fortune have lost interest in the tiresome business of self-government. Rather than vote or read the Constitution – a document as tedious as the trust agreements that the family lawyers occasionally ask them to sign — the heirs prefer to go to Acapulco or Aspen to practice macrobiotic breathing. They have better things to do with their lives than to be bothered with the details of preserving their freedom. They spend their time making themselves beautiful, holding themselves in perpetual readiness for the incarnations promised by the dealers in cosmetics and religion.

…  By abdicating their authority and responsibility, the sovereign people also relinquish their courage.

— From “The Precarious Eden”, published in Money and Class in America, Lewis Lapham (1988)

.

Unfortunately, the class that has led America — and done so well during our first two centuries — appears to have lost interest in the project.  They prefer to skim their profits off the top, and hope the ship of state drifts along in the trade lanes (and stays off the rocks).  Reform must come from us, not them.

Who and what is America? How is it possible to sustain the promise of democracy without the revenue to pay for all the degrees of subsidy and entitlement? If the federal bureaucracy in Washington is incompetent as well as corrupt, is it because the constitutional machinery has broken down, or because the ruling and possessing classes had decided that the practice of democratic government was both a risk and a luxury that they were no longer willing to finance?

… The task of restoring belief in the democratic idea — as opposed to promoting the ritual fictions of sham democracy made of Fourth of July speeches and editorials in USA Today — presupposes the collaboration of an oligarchy that sees some advantage in the enterprise.

— From “Democracy at Bay”, published in The Wish for Kings, Lewis Lapham (1993)

(2)  The first step to a solution

It’s not a new discussion, and has obsessed Europe’s Left for generations.  The form of their discussion is foreign to us, but we can learn much by ripping it free from its original context, much as America’s Founders did with the political theory of their time.

Weber points us toward Nietzsche as the common source for serious thinkers of the twentieth century. He also tells us what the single fundamental issue is: the relation between reason, or science, and the human good. When he speaks of happiness and the last man, he does not mean that the last man is unhappy, but that his happiness is nauseating. An experience of profound contempt is necessary in order to grasp our situation, and our capacity for contempt is vanishing.

Weber’s science presupposes this experience, which we would call subjective. After having encountered it in Nietzsche, he spent the greater part of his scholarly life studying religion in order to understand the non-contemptible, those who esteem or revere and are therefore not self-satisfied, those who have values …

— From The Closing of the American Mind, chapter “Values”, Allan Bloom (1987)

The first step is not knowledge.  Not logic.  But rage, contempt at what we have become.  From that other things can flow, good or bad depending on our character.

“Anger is easy. Anger at the right person, at the right time, for the right reason, is difficult.”
— Aristotle, in the Nicomachean Ethics, book IV, chapter 5 (lightly paraphrased)

“Telemachus, now is the time to be angry.”
— Odysseus, when the time came to deal with the Suitors. From the movie The Odessey (1997)

In this case the time is now.  The reason is the preservation of our nation.  The target is ourselves, how we have become less than we were.  Less than we should be.  Less than we can be.

This is the opposite of most proposals offered today, which suggest blaming some combination of the world, the rich, the poor, terrorists, foreigners, or whatever.  Or our leaders, who don’t kiss our boo-boos and cut the cake unfairly.  Everybody is responsible, except us.  Folks proposing such views suggest that we adopt the attitude of alarmed cattle.  Or mice.

(3)  The second step to a solution

The second step:  accepting responsibility for our fate, our lives.  Others might be enemies or obstacles, but we must stand upright to begin walking the road to reform.

(4)  For more information from the FM site

To read other articles about these things, see the FM reference page on the right side menu bar.  Of esp interest these days:

Posts about America — are we sheep?

  1. Americans, now a subservient people (listen to the Founders sigh in disappointment), 20 July 2008
  2. de Tocqueville warns us not to become weak and servile, 21 July 2008
  3. The American spirit speaks: “Baa, Baa, Baa”, 5 August 2008
  4. We’re Americans, hear us yell: “baa, baa, baa”, 6 August 2008
  5. This crisis will prove that Americans are not sheep (unless we are), 8 January 2009
  6. About security theater, a daily demonstration that Americans are sheep, 25 January 2009
  7. Are we citizens? Or peasants?, 21 May 2009

Posts on the FM site about solutions, ways to reform America:

  1. Diagnosing the Eagle, Chapter III – reclaiming the Constitution, 3 January 2008
  2. Obama might be the shaman that America needs, 17 July 2008
  3. Obama describes the first step to America’s renewal, 8 August 2008
  4. Let’s look at America in the mirror, the first step to reform, 14 August 2008
  5. Fixing America: shall we choose elections, revolt, or passivity?, 16 August 2008
  6. Fixing American: taking responsibility is the first step, 17 August 2008
  7. Fixing America: the choices are elections, revolt, or passivity, 18 August 2008
  8. What happens next? Advice for the new President, part one., 17 October 2008
  9. What to do? Advice for the new President, part two., 18 October 2008
  10. How to stage effective protests in the 21st century, 21 April 2009
  11. Sources of inspiration for America’s renewal, 23 April 2009

.

97 thoughts on “The first step on the road to America’s reform”

  1. FM: Tea parties are not a secret club, they just don’t have a litmus test yet. Lots of the local groups have websites, they post pix and videos to bloggers and each other — and don’t rely on Wikipedia or the press to tell find out what they and others are protesting. As soon as everybody gets together and comes up with a collective manifesto, I’ll try to remember to let you know! I have no idea why you simply assume that my experience consists solely of “talking to a few people at [my] local protest,” and I can hardly agree, either implicitly or explicitly, with items on a platform which does not yet exist. It all probably makes more sense to folks who have a higher tolerance for ambiguity at the outset of any venture. It will either come into focus further down the road, or die off by attrition.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: This is getting absurd. I did not ask for a “collective manefesto”. Link one site that lists their goals. Or a newspaper article. Something. Your repeated unsuported assertions that a usually reliable source is wrong carry zero weight with me.

    More importantly, your statements support my primary view that this is an incohate protest, not inherently different than asking for a good 5 cent cigar — or that we need not pay for the lavish dinner we’ve enjoyed.

    Also — I should have mentioned this earlier (I’ve said it frequently in other threads)… I agree with your observation that Wikipedia material must be treated carefully, esp with contraversal subjects. The links to sources is its most valuable feature, IMO.

  2. FM,see if this helps explain all in a minute and a half.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QPBE15DIy8E&feature=related
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: I don’t watch TV. If I did watch TV, it would not a politico talking. If I did want to watch a politico talking, it would not be Dennis Kucinich. If I did want to watch Dennis Kucinich talking, it would not be about economics (unlike, for example, his plan to end the Iraq War, which I thought was quite sensible).

    If whatever he’s talking about is a good idea, there is probably a favorable analysis of it by an expert. Since life is short, I’ll wait and read that.

    BTW — very impressive insert of the YouTube video into the comments. I didn’t know that could be done!

  3. Jeez ~ I guess I should have gone with my first thought and said Declaration of Independence instead of collective manifesto — in a clearly misguided attempt at lightening up!

    There isn’t any one site, or one article, or one Wiki entry that can list the Tea Party goals, because there isn’t any official/collectively agreed upon list, as yet. If citations are important to you, I should think it might be significant that Wikipedia’s putative list looks like practically the only thing in the article that is, in fact, unsourced. Perhaps you’re not aware of how Wikipedia entries are authored, but never mind. I offered my first person observations, as have others; you’ll obviously give them whatever weight it suits you to assign them. I’d just point out that inchoate was my characterization, and one that does not confirm your Wiki-based metaphors at all. Absurdity sounds about right though.

    Thanks for the challenge in any case.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: I am aware of how Wikipedia operates, and I don’t see how that is relevant. You have written many comments, none of which offer any evidence that it is wrong. Or any evidence whatsoever. If anything, your comments suggest that the Tea Party movements are an irrelevancy, much like the Left’s anti-war and anti-globalization protests (which include a mind-blowing range of subjects) — recreational protests, where like-minded folks get together and make noise.

  4. I agree with the commenter above who has discovered local political involvement. That’s where it should begin, and believe it or not, it’s a full-time job.
    * Start with your high-school board of governors, if you have kids that age. Raise issues of what’s being taught, defend the arts, make sure hirings and firings are proper.
    * Then on to the District School Board, your first elected position. Now you have to raise money — the great litmus test of whether your ideas make sense to a larger group of people.
    * Next stop, City Council, after crafting your resume and public image on a citizens’ committee or maybe a Planning Board. Here, for the first time, you come up against serious business interests — real estate mainly, and real world politics (the city’s need to raise money somehow, entice new business, countering an aging demographics.) At this point, you’ll find out if you are truly a reformer, or merely an accomodator. Good luck, if the former, although there’s usually room for one, the window dressing, on every governing board.
    * Next challenge is the County Board of Supervisors. Here you begin to encounter outside money, businesses based in Ohio who want to build a hospital or a garbage dump on a former ranch or public land site. To beat these guys, you’re going to be raising about $500K per run for office, working with professional campaign managers, spending 12 hours a day shaking hands and giving interviews. For four to six months straight, at a minimum. Exhilirating, eh!

    It’s what Aristotle meant when he said public life is the highest form of virtue.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: I disagree with much of this. First, very few people elected to entry-level political postions (e.g., local boards — utilities, schools, etc) are full-time politicos. Second, you are conflating holding political office with “local political involvment.” The first is a tiny sub-set of the second.

    Third, I wonder if Aristotle would consider a professional politican in America as living the highest form of virtue. From his “Nicomachean Ethics” (350 BC), Book One, chapter 2:

    If, then, there is some end of the things we do, which we desire for its own sake (everything else being desired for the sake of this) … clearly this must be the good and the chief good. … It would seem to belong to the most authoritative art and that which is most truly the master art.

    And politics appears to be of this nature; for it is this that ordains which of the sciences should be studied in a state, and which each class of citizens should learn and up to what point they should learn them; and we see even the most highly esteemed of capacities to fall under this, e.g. strategy, economics, rhetoric; now, since politics uses the rest of the sciences, and since, again, it legislates as to what we are to do and what we are to abstain from, the end of this science must include those of the others, so that this end must be the good for man.

    For even if the end is the same for a single man and for a state, that of the state seems at all events something greater and more complete whether to attain or to preserve; though it is worth while to attain the end merely for one man, it is finer and more godlike to attain it for a nation or for city-states.

  5. I believe that at least some of the problem here is that people posting are thinking in different time frames, without realizing that a problem can have different answers depending on the time frame. ( I first saw this in a 1984 book by Freeman Dyson called “Weapons and Hope” —

    “Roughly speaking, the time scale for American politicians working with an annual budget cycle is one year, the time scale for Soviet politicians is five years, for military and industrial planners is ten years, for mothers of young children twenty years, for grandparents fifty years; the time scale for historians and science fiction writers a hundred years. . . Many things which are absurd on a time scale of five years are reasonable or even inevitable on a time scale of fifty years.”

    Combine this with Barry Goldwater’s speech at the Republican convention of 1960 (this is from memory, but I promise the gist is correct)– he asked his name be withdrawn as a candidate and moved that the nomination of Nixon be made unanimous and said “If we work, we can take this party back. Let’s go to work.”

    I just flashed on Berthold Brecht’s comment after the failed East German uprising of 1953, where the Soviet puppet said that the people would have to win back the trust of the government: ” If the government does not trust the people, why doesn’t it just dissolve them and elect a new people?”

    As Jerry Pournelle is fond of pointing out, despair is a sin.
    .
    .
    FM Note: There has been debate among Christian theologians about despair — is it a sin? The standard answer is from “The Summa Theologica” of St. Thomas Aquinas. See the Second Part of the Second Part, Question 20 – Despair.

  6. Richard Rosenberg

    I want a smaller government that spends less, so that the taxes I pay may decline. However, if my efforts to curtail government spending fail, my taxes must go down nonetheless.

    I want to lend money at interest, often funding risky endeavors because of the handsome profits to be made. However, if the money I lend is not repaid by the borrower, I insist that it is repaid by someone else.

    It seems to me that those who would host a “tea party” share much in common with those who seek more direct government largess in the form of a bailout. Furthermore, the prevailing perception seems to be one where such beliefs are rooted in some sort of axiomatic view of one’s own importance. As a practical matter, it has led to successful prosecution of the only popular war since WW2: The war on our own children and grandchildren. It is nothing less than a simple lack of integrity, similar to the fine print of a credit card agreement or sub-prime loan. As to the emotional ingredients requisite for changes to the polity, which in turn may lead to actual policy changes, I liken it more to the stages of grief. We have yet to mourn for the death of our expectations, or even to admit they have passed on. Perhaps denial will indeed give way to anger at some point. When I consider though, that this may amount to no more than simple inter-generational theft, I am forced to admit that the transition from denial to constructive anger may depend on more gradual demographic changes. Barring the unforeseen major war, or other “outlier,” it might take a while. Nothing more than a pretty awful gut feeling, I hope.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: I do not understand the following text.

    “if my efforts to curtail government spending fail, my taxes must go down nonetheless.”

    The State and Federal governments are running deficits. If spending does not decrease, then taxes must inevitably increase. We cannot borrow forever, esp as both the Federal government and many large States (e.g., California) are nearing — or at — the upper limit of their credit.

  7. FM: ““Link one site that lists their goals.”

    Actually, if you’d be kind enough to direct me to a page which lists your goals, I’d be interested in a summary of what it is that you want to accomplish. If I’d been collecting Tea Party bookmarks along the way, I’d be happy to provide them, but there’s not much point in trying to chase down links which comport with my own 1st hand observations. They are what they are, and you’ve got plenty of other fish to fry.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: That is easy: About Fabius Maximus and this blog. The money paragraph:

    This blog discusses geopolitics – broadly defined as economics, government, sociology and the military arts – from an American’s perspective. This includes topics such as grand strategy, demographics, and peak oil. Here we seek a perspective from which to better see events and trends — things on the edge of our available information, on the edge of known theory.

    Any group activity requires goals, if it is to accomplish anything. If there are no goals, then it is a social activity — the default goal of people being to have fun.

  8. In order to feel contempt, you have to be awake. We are, I fear, in a dream state as a nation. How do you wake up a nation? Well, one way is to “Let it go off the road and crash.”, or “Let it burn”. Yes, pain and flames, which are both being metaphorically predicted and even advocated by some here will wake us up. I think FM is asking; How do we wake up our nation before it crashes and burns?

    The answer is; Honk your horns and yell Fire! Metaphorically speaking that is. In conversation, politely note that you are reading now, for a change, and thinking some too, and from what you are learning, (a plug for this site wouldn’t hurt), things look bad, really really bad. But before they walk away, which they will do, (Because who likes being woken from a nice dream?), note a few ways the world our children will soon be living in is going to suck big time. If our children don’t concern them, the game is up, we lose. But if they start to read a little, and think a little, one thing might lead to another and…

    All I can say is, it’s working on me, and I’m awake enough now that the contempt phase is kicking in.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: Nicely put. I wonder if part of the problem is that folks have cried wolf so often — about so many improbable things (global cooling, atomic war, terrorism, SwineFlu/AIDS/Herpes/AvianFlue/SwineFlu, etc) that near-certain and close-at-hand dangers have become invisible. The repeated false alarms might have had a deadening effect on America’s vision.

  9. Richard Rosenberg

    My meager attempt at irony, apparently all too meager. Quotes around the first two pairs of sentences were probably a good idea.

    Both so called “ideologies,” liberal and conservative, have perfected a sort of contortionism resulting in inter-generational theft. It has been an unmistakable feature of American political culture for almost thirty years. Deficit financed tax cuts are nothing more than deferred tax increases, and that is nothing less than immoral.

    My concern is that the anger which is IMO requisite to changing course may only develop slowly, more slowly than I would like. Because the burdens will fall most heavily on those who are not as politically organized or influential as their elders. Of course, our ability to borrow could run out before then, or some other event could intervene.

    Comments by the like of PIMCO’s Bill Gross notwithstanding, we don’t really know how close we are to the limits of federal borrowing. I’m concerned that we as citizens have demonstrated a commitment to finding that limit, and I would prefer we, rather than necessity, dictate where that limit is. As we have seen in spades, assumption of debt is among the easiest of our actions to rationalize. . .Especially when someone else gets the bill.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: That was my limitation, not yours. History records no sign that Fabius Maximus had a sense of humor; neither do I (unfortunately). I agree on all points with this.

  10. Re:90

    In control theory, there is a rich lexicon of descriptors for issues like the one you raise. Control system designers try to use past data, present data, and predicted future data for purposes of determining the right(optimal) corrective action to take. What’s not obvious to beginners, but really cool, is these three types of data are fundamentally different in their properties. This has profound implications for designing the system.

    Past data’s weakness is that it’s “old news”. It’s strength is that it’s intrinsically no noisier than real time data, but “old” noise can be suppressed by averaging, so it’s really reliable. The older it gets the more reliable it becomes through averaging.

    Real time data’s strength is it is current, its weakness is noise. Acted upon in real time, too much noise can “Fake you out”. Think of a soccer opponent “Putting the moves on you”, i.e. sending noise data deliberately in real time, which you may overreact to. You zig. He zag’s.

    Now let’s talk about future data. This is the noisiest, and most nearly worthless data of all. This is because future data estimates are often wildly corrupted by small noise in the real time data. The classic example is taking two sequential real time data points and estimating a slope to extrapolate forward in time. Small error in both data point values sometimes conspires to change the slope estimate a lot, ruining the predicted data’s utility. You can use predicted data in control systems, but usually just a little, and you can easily induce instability by using (reacting too much to) this data. I think people understand this and don’t react too much to predictions for this reason.

    In this context, I think our biggest problem now is our leaders keep finding ways to meet their parochial needs today, in real time, while gaming the system to make sure we discover and respond much too late.
    In control theory, the most devastating, really often insurmountable problem, is to have pure time lag, i.e. total delay of data. If the delay is too great, this will get you every time. By the time you find out, it’s too late to react. Lagging data is both “old” and “noisy”, the worst of all worlds, because you haven’t been averaging it, it just pops out of the lag element, “surprise! This used to be real time data!” Think of the debt problem this way, I think it helps.

  11. On Despair:

    Aquinas’ presentation would only be construed as approximating the “standard answer” by those who have not read Kierkegaard nor, especially, Saint Paul himself sufficiently. Aquinas’ theses suffer the infection of cloying occidents (not accidents) which all too pervasively characterize the post-Aristotelian tradition–chief of which is a Metaphysics of Presence.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: Always nice to see a comment from somebody with such a depth of knowledge. Thanks for posting!

  12. Money Unmade: Barter and the Fate of Russian Capitalism, by David M. Woodruff, Cornell University Press, 1999. Summary:

    Since the collapse of the Soviet Union, Russians have seen the ruble steadily lose ground to alternative means of payment such as barter and privately issued quasi-monies. Industry now collects as much as 70% of its receipts in nonmonetary form, leaving many firms with too little cash to pay salaries and taxes. In this ground-breaking book on the Russian economy, David Woodruff argues that Moscow’s inability to control the nation’s currency is not a carry-over from the Soviet past. Rather, the Russian government has failed to build the administrative capacity and political support demanded by monetary consolidation — a neglected but crucial aspect of capitalist statebuilding.

    Drawing on a vast array of empirical evidence, Woodruff shows how the widespread use of barter arose as local authorities tried to protect industry against the destructive effects of price increases and crude tax and accounting systems. As businesses fled or were driven from the money economy, provincial governments invented new ways to tax in kind and issued substitutes for the ruble. In turn, the federal authorities, unable to coerce firms either to operate in the money economy or to abandon business altogether, were forced to make accommodations to barter and to ruble alternatives. Woodruff describes the enormous fiscal difficulties that resulted and recounts the intense political battles over attempts to address the problem. Through an overview of monetary consolidation in other nations, Woodruff demonstrates that the struggles of the new Russian state have much to teach us about the political history of money worldwide. Sovereignty over money cannot, he argues, be imposed by government on a recalcitrant society. Nor can it be assumed as a by-product of disciplined policies aimed at market reform. Monetary consolidation is, at heart, a political achievement requiring political support.

  13. AIDs = Crying wolf ????
    You going to tell us Malaria is a media invention next ? Cholera is really bulimia ?People living in deserts just need to upgrade their sprinkler systems ?

  14. What a wonderful discussion. I couldn’t agree more with the sentiment that in the first step towards reform “the target is ourselves.” But there is an implication in that first step which has not been spelled out.

    Fabius, according to my reading of his comments, is really suggesting a change in our individual patterns of moral demands on ourselves and our social structure. This is much more than Tom Hayden’s suggestion that a political movement begins with an inner “desire to heal wounds inflicted on our dignity.” That desire, by itself, too easily translates into a traditional drive for power with all the inevitable corruptions (i.e. that there becomes no authority superior to its own and that the only issue is the winning and keeping of power.) That type of moral demand system is the status quo in our society today.

    Today’s “smug self-righteousness on the left and right” could possibly be replaced through a recognition that true authority is a kind of gift superior to the receiver of the gift. Such a recognition acts as a discipline on any political cause and perhaps is also the type of discipline that is the foundation of a “renewed sense of self-responsibility.”

    The contemporary bureaucracies of power can only be defeated by a vision which challenges their authority and ours at the deepest level.
    .
    .
    Fabius Maximus replies: What a wonderful quote by Tom Hayden! Thanks for posting this!

  15. Your #3 — accepting responsibility for our fate.
    The Bush-TARP bailout for the rich bankers was specifically to allow the Rich to AVOID accepting responsibility for their fate, for running insolvent Big Banks.

    Everybody wants to take credit for the good effects their efforts produce — and efforts produce effects. But along with your effort, the general environment outside your control produces effects. Thus, the same good effort in different places / times produces different effects. If the effects are good, it’s because you’re good. If bad, it’s because the environment is bad.

    FM, I totally agree with your contempt for those who complain about paying for gov’t, who yet don’t want the gov’t to stop spending. As a Libertarian, I learned that 60-80% of the folk knew that the gov’t spent too much, and wanted generally lower taxes and lower spending BUT, almost all involved activists have at least one cause where they want more gov’t power used. Such activists are willing to accept all the crap of the gov’t, for the “gem” of their favorite program.

    Until We the People, of the United States, in Order to Form a More Perfect Union … eschew increases in our Own Favorite Gov’t Program, the problem, and the gov’t, will keep getting bigger. And yes, Gov’t IS the problem.

    Because gov’t is force. And while force is needed to punish the bad, it is NOT needed to do the truly good. Every gov’t solution is a force based solution, and peace oriented folk must accept that. And work for voluntary solutions. Voluntary agreement is the opposite of force.

    Your comment responses are wonderful about this blog, even tho you usually disagree with me. It’s my not-quite rage at our disagreement that often motivates my response.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top